Trade Liberalization and Firm Adjustment: Evidence from Pakistan
Abstract
We study how firms adjust when they gain preferential access to a large export market. We exploit a trade liberalization in which the European Union, in 2014, removed tariffs on most exports of a lower-middle-income economy without requiring any reciprocal tariff cuts. Using administrative corporate tax records linked to product-level tariff exposure, we use variation in pre-reform EU tariffs across products to track how firms’ exports, labor, and capital respond. The preference raises exports: trade shifts toward the EU, and a one-percentage-point higher pre-reform tariff raises firm export value by about 19 percent, driven mainly by existing exporters selling more. Yet exposed firms do not grow on average: production wage bills decline, while capital stock and activity show no clear change. Beneath this average, firms adjust in different ways. More productive firms gain more exports and shift from production labor toward capital, while less productive firms become less active. Large incumbent exporters expand exports while reducing production wage bills, whereas large non-exporters, which must first bear the sunk costs of entering export markets, build up their capital stock. These findings suggest that preferential access works through existing exporters selling more abroad and through changes in how firms combine labor and capital, rather than through firm expansion. The results highlight productivity and prior export experience as key dimensions shaping how firms in developing economies respond to market access.